|
A Brief
"Primer on Prophecy" |
|
1)
When an OT prophet spoke, it generally
is in reference to one of four time periods:
(Click
notes)
a)
The prophet's own time
b)
Israel's captivity in Babylon or their
restoration to the land of Israel after Babylonian exile
c)
The Messiah's first coming
(see
Messianic Prophecies)
d)
The Messiah's second coming
(see
Messianic Prophecies;
Table comparing Rapture versus Second
Coming)
2) A single prophecy may have
more than one fulfillment
Partial fulfillment in the near future
Complete and final fulfillment in the distant future
Without going into a lengthy discussion, the principle of near/partial and
distant/complete fulfillment is seen in God's teaching on the
Day of the Lord,
a phrase mentioned at least 19 times in the OT and 4 times in the NT and
from the context is clearly not a literal 24 hour day. The Day of the Lord was partially fulfilled in Israel's
(more accurately Judah's)
Babylonian captivity but awaits complete fulfillment when the Lord pours out
His final wrath upon all of mankind (including Israel) who continue to
reject His offer of salvation by grace through faith in the Messiah (we read
about this fulfillment most clearly in the Revelation of Jesus Christ).
3) A single prophecy may have a
significant GAP in time between as to when different aspects are fulfilled.
(The so-called "Law of Double Reference")
The idea is that a passage can be speaking of two different events separated
by a long period of time. In the passage these two events are "blended" into
one picture, with no apparent time gap. It is only by comparing Scripture
with Scripture that a time gap is uncovered.
For example,
Isaiah 61:1-2 records the following
prophecy -- (See related resource
The Incredible Prophecy of Isaiah 61:1-3)
"The
Spirit of the Lord GOD is upon me, because the LORD has anointed me to bring
good news to the afflicted. He has sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, to
proclaim liberty to captives, and freedom to prisoners,
(2a) to proclaim the favorable year of the
LORD,
(2b)
and the day of vengeance of our God,
to comfort all who mourn."
After His baptism, Jesus began His ministry in the
Jewish synagogue in Nazareth with the following declaration from Isaiah
61:1-2a:
"THE
SPIRIT OF THE LORD IS UPON ME, BECAUSE HE ANOINTED ME TO PREACH THE GOSPEL
TO THE POOR. HE HAS SENT ME TO PROCLAIM RELEASE TO THE CAPTIVES, AND
RECOVERY OF SIGHT TO THE BLIND, TO SET FREE THOSE WHO ARE DOWNTRODDEN, 19 TO
PROCLAIM THE FAVORABLE YEAR OF THE LORD."
20 And He closed the book, and gave it back to the attendant, and sat
down; and the eyes of all in the synagogue were fixed upon Him. 21
And He began to say to them, "Today this Scripture has been fulfilled in
your hearing." (Luke
4:18-21)
Jesus stated that the Messianic prophecy in
Isaiah 61:1-2a was fulfilled in His First Coming (literally "in your hearing". He will not
fulfill "the day of vengeance" in
Isaiah 61:2b until His Second Coming. His first coming was primarily as Redeemer and
Savior, whereas His second coming will be primarily as Righteous Judge. Thus
Isaiah 61:2 records prophecies that are separated by at least 2000 years.
Zechariah records a prophecy that demands
interpretation of a "gap" of time between verse 9 and verse 10...
Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion! Shout in triumph, O daughter of
Jerusalem! Behold, your king is coming to you; He is just and endowed with
salvation, humble, and mounted on a donkey, even on a colt, the foal of a
donkey. 10 And I will cut off the chariot from Ephraim, and the horse from
Jerusalem; and the bow of war will be cut off. And He will speak peace to
the nations; and His dominion will be from sea to sea, and from the River to
the ends of the earth. (Zechariah
9:9-10)
Zechariah 9:9 is quoted in part by Matthew
and was fulfilled when Jesus rode into Jerusalem on "Palm Sunday". Matthew
records
Now this took place that what was spoken through the prophet might be
fulfilled, saying, SAY TO THE DAUGHTER OF ZION, 'BEHOLD YOUR KING IS COMING
TO YOU, GENTLE, AND MOUNTED ON A DONKEY, EVEN ON A COLT, THE FOAL OF A BEAST
OF BURDEN. (Mt
21:4-5, see also John 12:14,15)
Zechariah 9:10 refers a time yet future
when at the Second Coming the King of kings will establish peace and will
rule from "sea to sea, and from the River to the ends of the earth".
4) This website advocates and
practices a literal approach to the interpretation all Scripture, including prophetic Scripture.
(Click discussion of
interpretation in section on
inductive study)
Succinctly and simply stated if the
plain
sense makes good sense, then refrain from trying to make some
other sense out of the passage or you may end up with nonsense.
For example, if a text says 1000
and there is no clear reason from the context that would suggest it should
be interpreted any other way, then it will be interpreted as literal 1000.
Otherwise one opens the door to the limits of the expositor's imagination.
Furthermore, if a verse or phrase that could be interpreted literally is
deemed by someone as a passage that should not be interpreted literally, it
opens any and every verse of Scripture to the inherent danger of non-literal
interpretation. In fact, a spiritual interpretation of the literal bodily
resurrection of believers had the effect that a non-literal interpretation
will almost always have on believers...confusion and disturbance, as Paul
explained to Timothy writing that...
Men (teachers or leaders such as
Hymenaeus and Philetus - whose "talk" which could have included non-literal
"interpretation")...have gone astray from the truth saying that the
resurrection has already taken place, and thus they upset the faith of some.
(See notes
2 Timothy 2:18)
How might the resurrection have already
taken place? In First Thessalonians (1Th 4:16, 17-see notes
1Th 4:16;
4:17)
Paul had clearly taught that there would be a bodily resurrection,
but these men took a non-literal approach and "spiritualized" or
"allegorically interpreted" the resurrection
(allegory = form of literature in which a story points to a
hidden or symbolic parallel meaning).
What was the result? Upsetting of the faith of some of the believers. And do
we not see the same effect of non-literal handling of the Scriptures today?
Indeed we do -- witness for example the many genuine believers who do not
even want to even read the book of the Revelation simply because of the
widely divergent, confusing interpretations that have arisen from the
profusion of non-literal interpretations which have opened the door wide to
allegorization and/or spiritualization of the truth of God's final victory.
5)
A clear understanding of the history
of Israel is the key to unlocking prophecy
From Genesis to Revelation, the Word of God centers on Israel and the Jew. If you want to accurately interpret prophecy you
must understand how God deals with Israel in both Testaments. Israel is
God's timepiece and is the key to unlocking the prophetic Scriptures. If you
"replace" the Jew with the church in your interpretative scheme, you will
fail to understand God's prophetic timetable for His chosen people, and thus
fail to understand much of prophecy, especially that relating to Israel. You
must receive the word of God in its literal, natural sense, allowing
scripture to interpret scripture and refraining from interpreting a passage
with based on a brand of theology you have been taught (be it
dispensationalist, reformed, etc), and then you will see clearly that God is
not yet finished with Israel or the Jew.
6) Keep in mind that every prophecy is
related to other prophecies like threads in a finely woven tapestry.
No single chapter has all the prophecies
but predictive prophecies are interspersed throughout Scripture from Genesis
to Revelation. This fact alone indicates that it is mandatory that study of
prophecy calls for the student to be diligent to rightly divide the Word of
truth, interpreting literally and logically, avoiding a given "brand" of
"systematic theology" in which one interprets passages in a way that "fits"
one's system.
Dr John Walvoord notes that...
In the history of the church the
eschatological or prophetic portions of Scripture have suffered more from
inadequate interpretation than any other major theological subject. The
reason for this is that the church turned aside from a normal and
grammatical literal interpretation of prophecy to one that is nonliteral and
subject to the caprice of the interpreter. (Walvoord, J. F. The Prophecy
Knowledge Handbook. Wheaton, Ill.: Victor Books. 1990)
7) Fulfilled predictive
prophecy serves to increase our faith and resolve to hold fast to the
certainty that those aspects of God's prophetic program which are as yet
unfulfilled will surely come to pass just as He has sovereignly ordained.
For example in the study of Daniel
9:24-27, literal interpretation gives a very specific time for the arrival
or First Coming of Messiah (see notes
Daniel 9:25)
and then accurately predicts His Crucifixion (see notes
Daniel 9:26).
Both of these events are now history and thus sound forth a clear,
reliable testimony that not one good word of God has ever failed, and assure
us (literalists) that the literal fulfillment of
Daniel 9:27
is just as certain. The result is that our faith is strengthened to fight
the good fight. |
Daniel 9:4-27
THE BACKBONE OF PROPHECY
1)
Daniel 9:24-27-
Represents one of the key verses
regarding "end times" prophecy
Daniel 9:24-27 holds the key to all
prophetic interpretation and as such is the backbone of biblical prophecy.
Ray Pritchard writes that
If you understand what these verses mean,
you will have a good framework for understanding all that the Bible says
about the future. Miss this, and Revelation will be a mystery to you…. What
is presented here in a condensed form is greatly expanded in the New
Testament. This passage is the key that unlocks many other biblical
prophecies." Pritchard goes on to add that "If you have wondered where
certain popular writers get the concept of a future seven-year Tribulation
period, you will find the answer in this passage. Jesus refers to it in Mt
24:15 as does Paul in 2Th 2:1, 2, 3, 4. And the amazing events of
Rev 6-19 are simply an expansion of Da 9:27. What is presented here in a
condensed form is greatly expanded in the New Testament. This passage is the
key that unlocks many other biblical prophecies."
Chuck Swindoll says that "the vision of
the seventy weeks revealed in Daniel 9:24-27 is undoubtedly "the
backbone of Biblical prophecy" concerning Israel, Christ, and the
Antichrist. It is also true that fewer predictions in Scripture have been
interpreted in as many ways as have the seventy weeks of Daniel.
John Walvoord writes that
The interpretation of the revelation
given to Daniel concerning the seventy weeks (Daniel 9:24-27) constitutes
one of the determining factors in the whole system of prophecy. The
attention given to it by all schools of interpretation, and the attacks upon
the authenticity of the book itself combine to focus the white light of
investigation upon it. The interpretation of this passage inevitably colors
all other prophetic views, and a proper understanding of it is the sine
qua non of any student of prophecy." (Bolding added; Bibliotheca Sacra,
volume 101, page 30, Jan-Mar, 1944)
2)
Daniel 9:24-27 -
Outlines the future history of
Israel
As will be discussed below, Daniel 9:24-27 lays out in summary form a
timetable of the events that will impact Israel. There is no reference
whatsoever to "the church" in this passage, although some commentators still
imagine some reference to "the church."
a) The Jews could have known the time of the Messiah's arrival.
b) The Jews will be able to know the time of the "Anti-Messiah's"
("Anti-christ") arrival (cf Mt 24:15, 2Th 2:1, 2, 3, 4).
3) Provides clear evidence that the Bible is inspired by God
The accuracy of the prediction of the
coming of Messiah, Prince, is indisputable evidence of that the Bible is not
a book inspired by man but could only have been inspired by God Who Alone
knows the future.
Sir Isaac Newton, who wrote a discourse
on the topic, said we could stake the truth of Christianity on that prophecy
alone, made five centuries before Christ.
Respected pastor and author Ray
Stedman writes that Daniel 9:24-27 is
one of the strongest evidences to prove
the divine inspiration of the Bible. Many (believers) are frequently asked
why (they) believe the Bible to be the Word of God, and it is helpful to
know certain passages which clearly set forth predictive elements that are
unmistakable and which do indicate the ability of the Bible to predict
events far in the distant future. This could only be by divine power....(Daniel
9:24-27) pinpoints the exact moment in history when the Jewish
Messiah would present Himself to the Jewish people, and it does so over five
hundred years before the event took place. It is so plain and detailed that
it has always been an acute embarrassment to Jewish commentators.
4) Substantiates the truth that God is completely
sovereign
The prophecy in Daniel 9:24-27 is so
compellingly accurate, that it leaves no doubt that God is sovereign and in
full control over time and the affairs of men. This grand truth should
encourage the saint and frighten the sinner who is not yet saved to consider
the claims.
5) Has spurred many (Jews and Gentiles) to consider the claims of the
Messiah
Although many of the stories are
anecdotal (see below), the truth in Daniel 9:24-27 has caused many who seek
to refute these prophecies find that they are confronted with indisputable
evidence of the Messiah.
6) Refutes the attempt by many to question the date of writing of Daniel's
prophecies
Liberal scholars, both Gentile and Jew,
have tried to late-date Daniel in order to remove the onus of predictive
prophecy. They say the book was written after the events occurred but in
such a way as to appear that it was written beforehand. Daniel 9:24-27 is an
irrefutable witness that the prophecy of the Messiah's coming and being cut
off is true. Since, no one "late-dates" Daniel to the time of Christ,
Daniel 9:24-27 is one clear case of predictive prophecy, which establishes
the credibility of everything else. This observation also explains why the
critics try so hard to debunk this passage.
Henry Morris adds that Daniel's
prophecy was given...well over half a
millennium before its fulfillment. The probability that Daniel could guess
the date of the manifestation and crucifixion of the Messiah is
essentially zero. Only supernatural inspiration can account for
fulfilled prophecies like this. In fact, these events were fulfilled almost
two centuries even after the date assigned to Daniel by scholars who deny
that such prophecies can valid!" (Morris,
Henry: Defenders Study Bible. World Publishing - an excellent
resource from a conservative, literal viewpoint by one of the world's
leading scholars on creationism)
7) Stimulates a heightened expectation of the imminent return of the Messiah
(see Titus 2:13-note
and word study on
prosdechomai = looking for expectantly)
This statement applies to Daniel in
general also, for no book in the Bible says more about the so called end
times than Daniel. Many orthodox and conservative Jews believe the
time is ripe for the coming of Messiah. They see Israel's return to her
homeland after more than 1,900 years of national dispersion as having great
prophetic significance. They believe the May, 1948 rebirth of Israel and
waves of immigration (which is the meaning of the Hebrew word aliyah)
from all over the world are converging with many other factors to set the
stage for the predicted coming of a national Deliverer. They see the coming
of this Messiah as being good not only for Israel but for the whole earth.
According to the prophet Isaiah, He will cause the nations to
beat their swords into plowshares, and
their spears into pruning hooks; nation shall not lift up sword against
nation, neither shall they learn war anymore (Is 2:4-see
notes)
To quote from an email received February
4, 2004 from "The Temple Mount and Land of Israel Faithful Movement" (an
Orthodox Jewish group based in Jerusalem)
"The Hand of G_d appears again and again
in Jerusalem and the Temple Mount...to purify the Temple Mount and
immediately rebuild the house of G_d as the climax of the exciting
redemptional times in which we are now living in Israel which will open
the Eastern Gate for the coming of Mashiach ben David", this latter name
of course referring to the expected Messiah. Interestingly, both Jews and
Christians share the belief that a period of turmoil and distress will
precede the coming of Messiah. The Jewish document called "Talmudic Sages"
draws a dark picture of this time. Accordingly, one of these Jewish sages
wrote, "Let him [Messiah] come, but let me not see him" (Sanh. 98b).
INTERPRETATION OF
Daniel 9:24-27:
CHRISTOLOGICAL OR
NON-CHRISTOLOGICAL?
THAT IS THE QUESTION
See
Prophecy Primer
One
of the most respected names in the study of Bible prophecy, Dr. John
Walvoord, writes some sage remarks regarding the interpretative difficulties
of Daniel 9:24-27:
In the concluding four verses of Daniel
9, one of the most important prophecies of the Old Testament is
contained...Although many divergent interpretations have been advanced in
explanation of this prophecy, they may first be divided into two major
divisions, namely, the Christological and the non‑Christological
views. The non‑Christological approach may be subdivided into the
liberal critical view and the conservative amillennial view.
The
Christological camp interprets the first sixty-nine weeks of Daniel
as culminating in Christ while the non‑Christological camp finds
fulfillment of Daniel’s prophecy in events before or after Christ.
The
non-Christological group attempts to find fulfillment of the
Daniel's 70 Weeks in the events leading up to the persecution of Antiochus
Epiphanes (see
Daniel notes
and
additional discussion). In 168 B.C., a pagan altar was constructed on top of the great
altar of burnt sacrifices, and a pagan sacrifice was offered under the reign
of Antiochus Epiphanes. This act precipitated the Maccabean revolt which
Antiochus attempted unsuccessfully to put down with great cruelty (167-164
B.C.).
Recall that Daniel was written in two languages, Hebrew and Aramaic. From
Daniel 2:4b to Da 7:28, 8:1 the language is Aramaic for the focus is on the
Gentile world powers that would interact with Israel, and from Daniel 8:1
onward the focus of the book turns from the future of the Gentile world
powers to the future of Israel.
Another interesting observation is that in Daniel 9 Yahweh or
Jehovah is used seven times but no where else in the entire book!
Why would the Spirit inspire the usage in this chapter? Jehovah is God's
covenant name and this chapter preeminently emphasizes that He will keep His
promise to bring the Jews back to their land, the land He promised in
covenant to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
Daniel wrote chapter 9 about 538
BC and had lived long enough to have witnessed the fulfillment of the
prophecy in
Daniel 2 that predicted Babylon would give
way to another kingdom the Medo-Persians. It is worth remembering that
Daniel would be about 82 years old and yet he is still standing fast
as a man of the Word and of prayer. What Daniel discovered as he read
Jeremiah's prophecy (Jer
25:11,12 or a letter Jeremiah wrote to the exiles =
Jer 29:10) provoked him to prayer, which
presents a basic principle that the foundation of prayer is the Word of God.
Jesus taught that
If you abide in Me, and My words abide
in you, ask whatever you wish, and it shall be done for you.' (Jn15:7,
cp Jas 5:15, 16)
So as we look at the Word of God, we
know how to pray. In prayer we align ourselves, our desires, our actions,
our petitions, with the Word of God . And we align our lives with the word
of God.
It was
C
H Spurgeon who said
Oh! That you studied your Bibles more!
Oh! That we all did! How we could plead the promises! How often we should
prevail with God when we could hold Him to His word, and say, 'Fulfill this
Word unto Thy servant, whereon Thou hast caused me to hope.' Oh! It is grand
praying when our mouth is full of God's Word, for there is no word that can
prevail with Him like His own.
At
the time the prophecy recorded in Daniel 9 was given, the Babylonian Empire
had fallen to the Medo-Persian Empire. Cyrus (also referred to as Darius)
was in power. Although the Jewish exiles were now the captives of the
Medo-Persians, Daniel retained his position as prime minister because of his
integrity. Daniel received his revelation in the year 538 BC, about 67 years
after he had been taken captive.
Resources to Aid
Study of Daniel 9:24-27
Click
listing of commentaries categorized by
their interpretative approach to the book of Daniel and especially Daniel
9:24-27 so that you can be a Berean (Acts 17:11-note)
Click
brief refresher on some
basic principles of interpreting Bible prophecy.
EXPOSITION OF DANIEL 9:24-27
VERSE BY VERSE
Seventy
weeks
(Lv 25:8; Nu 14:34;
Ezek 4:6)
Literally 70
sevens or 70 units of seven. (Click
discussion of why the number 70 and its
relationship to Sabbath rests). See John Whitcomb's analysis
of the Hebrew word "weeks" -
Daniel's Great Seventy-Weeks Prophecy An
Exegetical Insight -- By John C. Whitcomb
(Only the first portion can be
view at no charge but see
Theological Journal Subscription info)
(List
of 22 journals - 500 yrs of articles searchable by topic or verse!
Incredible Online Resource!)
The NIV (see above)
is easier to understand than the KJV and NAS (both of which translate "seven"
with the word "week")...
Seventy 'sevens' are decreed
Weeks (07620) (shabuwa', sabua' or shabua')
means simply a "unit of seven" and could refer to seven of anything. Our
English equivalent is "heptad"
which means "a group of seven".
Shabuwa' - 20x in 17v in NAS - Ge
29:27, 28; Ex 34:22; Lv 12:5; Nu 28:26; Dt. 16:9, 10, 16; 2Chr. 8:13; Je
5:24; Ezek 45:21; Da 9:24, 25, 26, 27; 10:2, 3
The Theological Wordbook adds
that shabua'
occurs 20 times in the OT, always indicating a period of seven. Indeed, the
word obviously comes to us from sheba' and could literally be translated
always as "seven-period."
(Harris,
R L, Archer, G L & Waltke, B K Theological Wordbook of the Old Testament.
Moody Press)
Three times in the OT, shabua' is modified by the Hebrew word for days, with the "seven days" referring to a literal
week (Ezek 45:21, Da 10:2, 3), 6 times in Daniel 9:24, 25, 26, 27 it is used as a unit of seven without an added
unit of time and 11 times it is used to mean a literal week of seven days
(Ge 29:27,28, Lev 12:5) with 8 of 11 uses referring to the
Jewish Feast of Weeks or Pentecost (Ex 34:22, Nu 28:26, Dt
16:9 [x2], Dt 16:10, 16, 2Chr 8:13, Jer 5:24). Note for example Leviticus
12:5 which describes the length of time a mother shall remain unclean
declaring
she shall be
unclean for two weeks... (literally "two sevens" or "two
units of seven")
Observe that the context
most naturally leads to the interpretation as "two units of seven"
days. The Hebrew omits the word for "day", because the meaning
is clear from the context. By comparison the Hebrew Da 9:24, 25, 26,
27 omits the unit of time, because in context the
time is most naturally understood as "years".
Assuming a literal interpretation,
seventy weeks or units of seven (seventy heptads, units of measure) can be
conveniently divided as follows...
Daniel 9:24 - a comprehensive picture of
the entire prophecy
Daniel 9:25 - the first 69 sevens (483
years)
Daniel 9:26 - the events between the 69th
and 70th sevens
Daniel 9:27 - conclusion punctuated by
the 70th seven of 7 years.
Remember one of our
simple but foundational "rules" in interpreting prophecy is that if
the
plain sense makes good sense,
don't try to make some other sense
or it may result in
nonsense.
To say that the events described in Da
9:24, 25, 26, 27 occurred in 490 days, 490 weeks or 490 months
makes no sense ("nonsense") from the context! Even older commentaries see
this as only making sense if it is interpreted as years.
For example Gill writes that
this space of "seventy" weeks is not to be understood of weeks of days;
which is too short a time for the fulfillment of so many events as are
mentioned; nor were they fulfilled within such a space of time; but of weeks
of years, and make up four hundred and ninety years.
It is often said that in interpretation
of Scripture, "context is king" and the verses that follow (Da
9:24, 25, 26, 27) provide the major "clue" as the most appropriate unit of
time one should use to modify the "seventy units of seven". The rationale
for interpreting the unit as years is discussed in more detail
elsewhere (click
here).
In summary, the context most logically leads one to
conclude that Daniel is referring to "seventy sevens" of "years" for a total of
490 years (70 x "7" years = 490 years).
Click
for more detailed discussion of why
"years" is the most appropriate unit of time regarding the
interpretation of the 70 x 7's.
Although many if not most of the older
commentaries such as Matthew Henry, Adam Clarke, et al, are
woefully inadequate when it comes to the interpretation of prophecy
(primarily because they have fallen into the "abyss" of replacing Israel
with the Church in their interpretation of Old Testament prophecies - see
Israel of God), there
are a few relatively good older commentaries, and one is by Jamieson-Fausset-Brown
which was published in 1871. It is refreshing to read their clear and cogent
literal interpretation of Daniel 9:24...
Seventy weeks -- namely, of years;
literally, "Seventy sevens"; seventy heptads or hebdomads; four hundred
ninety years; expressed in a form of "concealed definiteness"
[Hengstenberg], a usual way with the prophets. The Babylonian captivity
is a turning point in the history of the kingdom of God. It
terminated the free Old Testament theocracy. Up to that time Israel, though
oppressed at times, was; as a rule, free. From the Babylonian captivity
the theocracy never recovered its full freedom down to its entire suspension
by Rome; and this period of Israel's subjection to the Gentiles is to
continue till the millennium (Re 20:1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10,
11, 12, 13, 14, 15), when Israel shall be restored as head of the New
Testament theocracy, which will embrace the whole earth. The free theocracy
ceased in the first year of Nebuchadnezzar, and the fourth of Jehoiakim; the
year of the world 3338, the point at which the seventy years of the
captivity. begin. Heretofore Israel had a right, if subjugated by a foreign
king, to shake off the yoke (Jdg 4:1-5:31 2Ki 18:7) as an unlawful one, at
the first opportunity. But the prophets (Jer 27:9, 10, 11) declared it to be
God's will that they should submit to Babylon. Hence every effort of
Jehoiakim, Jeconiah, and Zedekiah to rebel was vain. The period of the world
times, and of Israel's depression, from the Babylonian captivity to the
millennium, though abounding more in afflictions (for example, the two
destructions of Jerusalem, Antiochus' persecution, and those which
Christians suffered), contains all that was good in the preceding ones,
summed up in Christ, but in a way visible only to the eye of faith. Since He
came as a Servant, He chose for His appearing the period darkest of all as
to His people's temporal state. Always fresh persecutors have been rising,
whose end is destruction, and so it shall be with the last enemy,
Antichrist. As the Davidic epoch is the point of the covenant-people's
highest glory, so the captivity is that of their lowest humiliation.
Accordingly, the people's sufferings are reflected in the picture of the
suffering Messiah. He is no longer represented as the theocratic King, the
Antitype of David, but as the Servant of God and Son of man; at the same
time the cross being the way to glory (compare Da 9:1-27 with Da 2:34, 35,
44 Da 12:7). In the second and seventh chapters (of Daniel), Christ's first
coming is not noticed, for Daniel's object was to prophesy to his nation as
to the whole period from the destruction to the re-establishment of Israel;
but this ninth chapter minutely predicts Christ's first coming... (Commentary
Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible — Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible
Commentary)
Joseph Seiss, was born into a family
that worshipped in the Moravian denomination, and later joined the Lutheran
Church in which he became a pastor despite having very minimal formal
theological education. His commentary on the book the Revelation, entitled "The
Apocalypse" (The
Apocalypse- Lectures on the Book of Revelation - Limited Preview), is one of the best old commentaries available as he
held generally to a literal interpretation of the Scriptures.
|
SEVENTY SEVENS
The 3 Divisions |
|
7 SEVENS
(49 years) |
Rebuilding of
Jerusalem
(cannot be dogmatic) |
62 SEVENS (434 years)
(49 + 434 = 483 years) |
First Advent
of
the Messiah |
GAP
Between Week 69- 70 |
1 SEVEN
(7 years) |
"The
Tribulation"
Seventieth Week of Daniel |
Have been decreed
determined (KJV)
settled
(Berkley)
marked out (New English Bible)
commanded (TLB)
God has set (GNB)
weeks have been fixed (BBE)
assigned
(GWT)
God has ordered (NCV)
Decreed
(02852) (chathak/hatak)
means something determined. This verb is in the perfect
mood which expresses a completed action. "God said it, so that settles it"
is the idea! The Hebrew root word basically means to "cut or divide", "to cut off"
and hence to decree or determine.
The picture conveyed
by chathak/hatak is of a settled decree by the LORD or
Jehovah
(Jehovah is always identified by LORD in all caps in the NAS = which distinguishes it from "Lord" = Adonai),
where
Jehovah
emphasizes that He is the covenant keeping God. In fact, in Daniel
Jehovah
is used only in Daniel 9
(Da 9:2, 9:4, 9:10, 9:13, 9:14,
9:20). This passage speaking of what God determines will come to pass emphasizes
that He is
sovereign and
thus is in complete control of the history of His people
Israel. The
Sovereign
One has marked out, ordained or predetermined the events
Israel will experience (and He does so without violating their free will -
Incomprehensible)! Stated another way, it is as if God has "cut off" a
segment of time and assigned it as the time during which He will bring about the deliverance and restoration of
His people, Israel, and His holy city, Jerusalem. What
God prophesies, He fulfills and thus His
plan will be completed in each of the 6 specific predictions in this verse
(cp Is 43:13, 44:7, 45:21, 46:10). The
Hebrew verb chathak/hatak is translated in the Greek
Septuagint (LXX) with
the Greek verb (suntemno)
that means to cut short, to bring to an end or to accomplish speedily (cp
the
Eternal
God's
perspective on time - Ps 90:4-note).
Gill also observes that the Hebrew verb chosen
here is especially apropos for
the word...to cut
aptly expresses the division, or section of these weeks into distinct
periods, as seven, sixty two, and one.
Jamieson adds that the meaning
is...
literally, "cut out," namely, from the
whole course of time, for God to deal in a particular manner with Jerusalem.
(Ed: And the course of time to deal "with the Jews" as predicted in
Leviticus - see
Seven Times Seventy)
For your
people and your holy city
Your People - Recall that the one
announcing this prophecy is the angel
Gabriel
(4x in Scripture - Da 8:16, 9:21, Lk 1:19, 26)
who addresses Daniel,
a Jew. It follows the phrase your people (cp same phrase in Da
10:14, 11:14 - referring to traitorous Jews, Da 12:1) refers to the Jews. If
you miss this important distinction, the entire prophecy will make
absolutely no sense!
Unlike the prophecies in Daniel 2 (cp Da
2:44, 45) and Daniel 7 (Da 7:3, 4, 5, 6, 7 - describing the Gentile empires
of Babylon, Medo-Persian, Greece and Rome)
which primarily relate to the Gentiles (which correlates with Da 2:4
thru Da 7:28 being written in Aramaic rather than Hebrew), Daniel 9:24, 25,
26, 27 is God's specific program for the Jews
and for Jerusalem.
It is surprising that some scholars who
seem to be generally "conservative" (e.g., Young, Keil, Leupold)
interpret your people
symbolically (allegorically) as a reference to the church (which even
the NT says is not revealed in the OT-- e.g., see Ep 3:1,2, 3-note,
Ep 3:4, 5-note,
Ep 3:6-note).
If you begin the interpretation of what
has to be one of the greatest, if not the greatest, prophecies of all
prophecies by misinterpreting to whom it is addressed, you are
destined to miss the great jewels of truth that lay hidden to an honest,
literal interpretation of this passage. For an excellent synopsis of the use
and dangers of allegorical interpretation see Dr Tony Garland's
articles (from his verse by verse study of the Revelation - which I highly
recommend =
A Testimony of Jesus Christ)...
1).
Art and Science of Interpretation
2).
The Rise of Allegorical Interpretation
3).
Understanding Symbols and Figures
4).
Understanding Numbers
Your holy city - In context
this is clearly a reference to the holy city of Jerusalem (cp references to
holy city - Neh 11:1; 11:18; Is 48:2; Isa 52:1; Da 9:24; Mt 4:5;
27:53; Re 11:2; 21:2; 21:10; 22:19).
Similar to their incorrect allegorical interpretation
of your people, the same group of commentators (e.g., Young, Keil,
Leupold) interpret your holy city as a reference
to the heavenly Jerusalem (cp Re 21:2-note)
despite the fact that there is nothing stated in the immediate
context
which
supports such an imaginative interpretation! This is why the wise Bible
student holds fast to the maxim that
context
is always king in interpretation. No where is this maxim more
important to apply than in the interpretation of Biblical prophecies. As stated earlier, if the plain sense
of the passage makes good
sense, don't try to make some other sense or it's potentially nonsense!
By the time these 490 years run their
course, God will have accomplished all 6 predictions, and in fact all will be
literally realized by Israel at the Second Coming of Messiah (See
Table comparing Rapture vs Second Coming)
when...
all Israel
will be saved; just as it is written, "THE DELIVERER (the Messiah) WILL COME FROM ZION, HE
WILL REMOVE UNGODLINESS FROM JACOB. AND THIS IS MY COVENANT WITH THEM, WHEN
I TAKE AWAY THEIR SINS. (Ro 11:26, 27-see
notes)
At that time the elect
(chosen) of Israel (the
remnant) will
recognize the Messiah and will repent and will turn to Him as their national
(and personal) Deliverer,
Savior and King. At this time Israel will be restored to
the land
(a common phrase in the OT which most often refers to the "promised land" -
but always check the context) in
fulfillment of God's promise to Abraham (Ge 15:18 - a promise never
completely fulfilled and never revoked). Observe that in a sense the
restoration of Israel from "exile" to the land of Palestine is ultimately an answer to Daniel’s prayer.
Note that although the
six accomplishments listed in this verse are addressed primarily to Israel, clearly
all of humanity will
be radically impacted by the fulfillment, some to the eternal praise of the
glory of God's grace and some to eternal punishment away from the presence
of the Lord (cp Mt 25:41, Mt 7:21-note,
Mt 7:22, 23-note,
2Th 1:7, 8, 9, 10)
Walvoord observes that...
Even in ruins, Jerusalem remains the city
set apart in the heart of God (cf. Da 9:20) and Daniel shared this love for
the city which is central in God's program for His kingdom both in the past
and the future. Unlike the prophecies of Daniel 2, 7, and 8, which primarily
related to the Gentiles, this chapter is specifically God's program for the
people of Israel, as Daniel would obviously interpret it. To make this
equivalent to the church composed of both Jews and Gentiles is to read into
the passage something foreign to the whole thinking of Daniel. The church as
such has no relation to the city nor to the promises given specifically to
Israel relating to their restoration and repossession of the land.
(Daniel: The key to Prophetic Revelation
-- free online)
THE SIX "BULLET POINTS"
OF THE DIVINE DECREE
(1) to
finish the transgression:
(Mt 1:21; 1Jn 3:8)
to let wrongdoing be complete (BBE).
Literally "to restrain firmly the
transgression "
The main idea as discussed more below is
that rebellion against God will end at the Second Coming of Christ and only
those Jews and Gentiles who are genuine believers in the Messiah will enter
into the Messianic Kingdom on earth. Note that although peace and
righteousness will be the order in the Christ's Millennial Kingdom, at the
end of this 1000 years there will be a brief time of final rebellion which
John describes...
7 And when the thousand years are
completed, Satan will be released from his prison,
8 and will come out to deceive the nations which are in the four corners of
the earth, Gog and Magog, to gather them together for the war; the number of
them is like the sand of the seashore (those who have been born during the
Millennium).
9 And they came up on the broad plain of the earth and surrounded the camp
of the saints and the beloved city (Jerusalem), and fire came down from
heaven and devoured them. (presumably they go to Hades and will be shortly
judged at the Great White Throne, Rev 20:11, 12, 13, 14, 15 -note)
10 And the devil who deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and
brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are also; and they will be
tormented day and night forever and ever. (see Rev 20:7-note;
Re 20:8-note;
Re 20:9-note;
Re 20:10-note)
Comment: See the notes on the
Revelation for a more detailed discussion. In short, observe that (1) this
rebellion is at the end of the 1000 years, (2) that Satan has been bound,
and (3) that men and women who are sinners have been born to the original
inhabitants of the Messianic Kingdom all of whom were believers. This is one
of the most incredible teachings in the Bible in my opinion, because it
leaves no doubt that Adam's seed infects all (Ro 5:12-note)
and we do not need the devil to deceive us and cause us to be unbelievers as
testified by the numerical estimate of "like the sand of the seashore"! It
is almost beyond comprehension to realize that the Messiah Himself if
reigning on earth and nevertheless these men and women refuse to believe in
Him!
For completeness, it should be noted that
there are two Hebrew verbs which are used to translate the phrase finish (click
explanation).
Jamieson has an interesting note
that...
The seventy years exile (in Babylon) was
a punishment, but not a full atonement, for the sin of the people; this
would come only after seventy prophetic weeks, through Messiah. (See note on
Seven Times More)
Moses' illustrates the meaning
of kala' (the Hebrew verbs for finish) describing the ending of the flood when
the fountains of
the deep and the floodgates of the sky were closed, and the rain from the
sky was restrained (kala') (Ge 8:2).
Israel's rebellion will be restrained at the
Second Coming of the Messiah
when a
remnant
will turn to Him in faith and the nation’s transgression and sins will be
forgiven. Zechariah records God's promise that when the Messiah returns
after the decreed 490 years
it will come about in all the land...that
two parts in it will be cut off and perish, but the third will be left
in it (the "elect" and believing
remnant). And I will bring the third part through the fire,
refine them as silver is refined, and test them as gold is tested. They will
call on My name, and I will answer them; I will say, 'They are My people,'
(a component of the New Covenant promised to Israel - see Jer 31:33, 32:38)
and they will say, 'The LORD is my God.' (Zech 13:8, 9)
Transgression (06588) (pesha')
means to rebel, revolt or to rise up in clear defiance to authority by
violation of a law, command, or duty. The fundamental idea is a breach of
relationship (civil or religious) between two parties. Pesha' speaks of
willful sins. And so the first item in God's program is to bring Israel's rebellion
against Him to an end.
Pesha' - 91v in the OT - Gen.
31:36; 50:17; Exod. 22:9; 23:21; 34:7; Lev. 16:16, 21; Num. 14:18; Jos.
24:19; 1 Sam. 24:11; 25:28; 1 Ki. 8:50; Job 7:21; 8:4; 13:23; 14:17; 31:33;
33:9; 34:6, 37; 35:6, 15; 36:9; Ps. 5:10; 19:13; 25:7; 32:1, 5; 36:1; 39:8;
51:1, 3; 59:3; 65:3; 89:32; 103:12; 107:17; Prov. 10:12, 19; 12:13; 17:9,
19; 19:11; 28:2, 13, 24; 29:6, 16, 22; Isa. 24:20; 43:25; 44:22; 50:1; 53:5,
8; 57:4; 58:1; 59:12, 20; Jer. 5:6; Lam. 1:5, 14, 22; Ezek. 14:11; 18:22,
28, 30f; 21:24; 33:10, 12; 37:23; 39:24; Dan. 8:12f; 9:24; Amos 1:3, 6, 9,
11, 13; 2:1, 4, 6; 3:14; 5:12; Mic. 1:5, 13; 3:8; 6:7; 7:18 and is rendered
in the NAS as breach of trust(1), rebellion(6), rebellious(1),
rebellious act(2), rebellious acts(2), transgression(37),
transgressions(45). Vine says that
pesha'
basically...signifies willful deviation from, and therefore rebellion
against, the path of godly living. Transgression
in this verse speaks of a definite rebellion against authority, and the
grammatical construction suggests that a specific transgression was
intended. This seems to be a reference to the rebellion by Israel
specifically against God and His Word.
Showers adds
that
this
rebellion was the root sin which prompted all of Israel’s other sins.
Gabriel was saying that Israel would not stop its rebellion against God’s
rule until these 490 years would run their course. In agreement with this,
other Scriptures indicate that Israel will not repent, turn to God and be
saved until the Second coming of Christ at the end of these 490 years
(Zech 12:10,11, 12, 13, 14, 13:1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9; Ro 11:25, 26, 27-note).
(The Most High God: Commentary on the Book of Daniel. Bellmawr, NJ: Friends
of Israel Gospel Ministry, Inc)
John Walvoord adds that
The most obvious meaning is that Israel's course of apostasy and sin and
wandering over the face of the earth will be brought to completion within
the seventy sevens. The restoration of Israel which Daniel sought in his
prayer would ultimately have its fulfillment in this concept. (Daniel: The key to Prophetic Revelation
-- online)
In regard to the
phrase finish
the transgression in
Daniel 9:24, the New American Commentary
(Daniel: Broadman & Holman Publishers) has this note
Most
authorities (eg KJV, NASB, NIV), taking the qere reading, have understood the Hebrew
verb in this first phrase as kālâ, “be complete, at an end,
finished, accomplished, spent.” Others (e.g., kethiv,
Wood, Young) have taken the word to be kālā, “shut
up, restrain, withhold.” If the latter is correct,
the idea could be that transgression is not completely stopped but
lessened. Yet it could also mean that transgression is restrained
completely, at least for a time. Thus the meaning would be very similar to
that of kālâ.
Comment:
This is a somewhat technical note on Kethiv versus Qere {explained below}
in Daniel 9:24. Keep in mind that in copying the Hebrew Bible,
the scribes did not alter any text they felt had been copied incorrectly.
In the Masoretic Text they noted in the margin what they thought the
written text should be and this was designated a Kethiv
(or Kethib or Ketib) which
literally means "what is written" and the marginal note is
called the Qere (Kere) an anglicized Aramaic word
which means "what is read". Until the time of the Masoretes, the
Hebrew Bible was written only with consonants. The Masoretes
(the name of the scholars whose work it was to maintain the tradition
which governed the production of copies of the biblical text, referred to
as the Masoretic Text) thought that vowels would clarify the
Scriptures and therefore began to copy the Hebrew texts with the
addition of vowels. When they
came across a word they thought was unclear by its normal vowels, they
would put the word in the margin with other vowels, changing the
meaning or intent. The word that was written in the text was called
the Kethiv and what was to be read was
called the Qere which
represented the variant marginal reading. There are about 1300 instances
of Kethiv-Qere in the Masoretic Text. This note would lead a
person reading the text to pronounce the Qere rather than
the Kethiv. Qere readings were intended either
to correct the Kethiv or to preserve variant
manuscript traditions. Now
are you totally confused?
(2) to
make an end of sin: (Lam
4:22; Col 2:14; Heb 9:26; 10:14) (Ezek 28:12)
Literally this means to seal up sins
(Young's
Literal).
Notice that the first three "bullet points" in Daniel 9:24 have to do with
sin.
Make an end (08552)
(tamam) basically means to restrict the flow or
movement of or to interrupt what is in progress or would naturally be in
progress (in this case Israel's committing of individual "sins").
The basic meaning of tamam speaks of completeness, of “being complete” or
“finished,” with nothing else expected or intended. The idea to bring
something to a successful end.
Tamam - 62v in the OT - Gen.
47:15, 18; Lev. 25:29; 26:20; Num. 14:33, 35; 17:13; 32:13; Deut. 2:14ff;
31:24, 30; 34:8; Jos. 3:16f; 4:1, 10f; 5:6, 8; 8:24; 10:20; 1 Sam. 16:11; 2
Sam. 15:24; 20:18; 22:26; 1 Ki. 6:22; 7:22; 14:10; 2 Ki. 7:13; 22:4; Job
22:3; 31:40; Ps. 9:6; 18:25; 19:13; 64:6; 73:19; 102:27; 104:35; Isa. 16:4;
18:5; 33:1; Jer. 1:3; 6:29; 14:15; 24:10; 27:8; 36:23; 37:21; 44:12, 18, 27;
Lam. 3:22; 4:22; Ezek. 22:15; 24:10f; 47:12; Dan. 8:23; 9:24 and is rendered
in the NAS as all(1), all gone(1), all spent(2), been completed(1),
blameless(1), blossoms(1), boil well(1), came to an end(1), cease(1), come
to an end(2), complete(2), completed(1), completely(3), consume(1),
consumed(4), count(1), destroyed(6), end(2), ended(3), fail(1), finally
perished*(1), finish(1), finished(7), full(1), gone(1), lie(1), make
perfect(1), meet an end(4), met an end(1), perished(4), ready(1), run(1),
show blameless(2), spent(1), utterly(1).
In short, this prophecy is saying that
sins will be controlled during the
Millennium and cease completely during
the succeeding eternal state in the New Heaven and New Earth. (Re
21:1, 2-note,
Re 21:8-note,
Re 22:15-note). The
Millennium
will be characterized by a "sealing up" of sin indicating that among the
citizens of the
Millennium,
sin will be rare and judgment for wrongdoing will be swift and just (see
Walvoord's comments below).
Keil writes that...
The figure of the sealing stands here in
connection with the shutting up in prison. Cf. Da 6:18, the king for greater
security sealed up the den into which Daniel was cast. Thus also God seals
the hand of man that it cannot move, Job 37:7, and the stars that cannot
give light, Job 9:7...The sins are here described as sealed, because they
are altogether removed out of the sight of God. (C. F. Keil, Biblical
Commentary on the Book of Daniel)
Sin
(02403)
means to miss the mark or to fall short of the divine standard. In contrast
the previous Hebrew word for transgression (pesha) indicates revolt
against the divine standard.
John Walvoord writes that...
The most obvious meaning is that Israel's
course of apostasy and sin and wandering over the face of the earth will be
brought to completion within the seventy sevens. The restoration of Israel
which Daniel sought in his prayer will ultimately have its fulfillment in
this concept. (Daniel: The key to Prophetic Revelation
-- online)
Ezekiel records that when Christ returns
and inaugurates His New Covenant with Israel, they
will no longer defile themselves with their idols, or with their
detestable things, or with any of their transgressions; but I will deliver
them from all their dwelling places in which they have sinned, and
will cleanse them. And they will be My people, and I will be their God.
(Ezekiel 37:23)
At the termination of these 490 years God adds
Moreover,
I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit within you; and I will
remove the heart of stone from your flesh and give you a heart of flesh. And
I will put My Spirit within you and cause you to walk in My
statutes, (God's empowerment and enablement) and you will be
careful to observe My ordinances (Israel's responsibility).
(Ezekiel 36:26, 27)
At that time, the Jews entering the Millennial Kingdom
with a "new heart" will have the supernatural "power" to restrain their sins
in everyday life. Matthew had prophesied that a virgin named Mary would
bear
a Son; and you shall call His name Jesus, for it is He who will save His
people from their sins. (Mt 1:21)
J Vernon McGee phrases it this way
The national sins of Israel will come to
an end at the second coming of Christ. They are just like any other people
or any other nation. They are sinners as individuals and as a nation. They
have made many mistakes as a nation (so have we), but God will make an end
to that. (McGee,
J V: Thru the Bible Commentary: Thomas Nelson
or
Logos)
(3) to
make atonement for iniquity:
(Lv 8:15; 2Chr 29:24; Is 53:10; Ro 5:10; 2Co
5:18, 19, 20; Col 1:20; He 2:17)
to make reconciliation for iniquity (KJV, NKJV)
to atone for
wickedness (NIV)
to cover iniquity (Young's Literal)
to
make expiation for iniquity (Darby)
Atonement (03722)
(verb kaphar = source of phrase "Yom Kippur" or Jewish
Day of Atonement)
is a verb that has reference to sin and means
to cover to wipe out, "to make...as harmless, non-existent, or
inoperative, to annul (so far as God's notice or regard is concerned), to
withdraw from God's sight, with the attached ideas of reinstating in His
favour, freeing from sin, and restoring to holiness." (Driver, S R: A
Dictionary of the Bible). In short, the idea is to cover sin by making a
sacrifice. Keil says the form of the verb indicates that it means "to cover
so thoroughly that the sin is obliterated."
Kaphar - 93v in the OT - Gen.
32:20; Exod. 29:33, 36f; 30:10, 15f; 32:30; Lev. 1:4; 4:20, 26, 31, 35; 5:6,
10, 13, 16, 18; 6:7, 30; 7:7; 8:15, 34; 9:7; 10:17; 12:7f; 14:18ff, 29, 31,
53; 15:15, 30; 16:6, 10f, 16ff, 20, 24, 27, 30, 32ff; 17:11; 19:22; 23:28;
Num. 5:8; 6:11; 8:12, 19, 21; 15:25, 28; 16:46f; 25:13; 28:22, 30; 29:5;
31:50; 35:33; Deut. 21:8; 32:43; 1 Sam. 3:14; 2 Sam. 21:3; 1 Chr. 6:49; 2
Chr. 29:24; 30:18; Neh. 10:33; Ps. 65:3; 78:38; 79:9; Prov. 16:6, 14; Isa.
6:7; 22:14; 27:9; 28:18; 47:11; Jer. 18:23; Ezek. 16:63; 43:20, 26; 45:15,
17, 20; Dan. 9:24 and is rendered in the NAS as appease(1), appease(1),
atone(3), atoned(2), atonement is made(1), atonement shall be made(1),
atonement was made(1), atoning(1), canceled(1), forgave(1), forgive(4),
forgiven(5), made atonement(3), made expiation(1), make atonement(71), makes
atonement(2), making atonement(1), pardon(1).
Kaphar is first found in Genesis where God
instructed Noah to
cover (kaphar
the ark) inside and out with pitch. (Ge 6:14)
Kaphar is used in most of the OT with the theological meaning
of to “cover over”, usually with the blood of a sacrifice, and thus
covering over sin in order to atone for sin (make reparation, amends
or satisfaction for an offense or a crime, by which reconciliation is
procured between the offended and offending parties). This symbolism is
drawn from the OT sacrificial system in which the blood was sprinkled over
the mercy seat in the temple, depicting that the sin of the people was
forgiven because it was covered by the blood (cf. Lev 16:15, 16)
Iniquity (05771)
('avon) expresses the concept of to bend, twist or distort and in
this context refers a twisting of the standard or deviation from it.
It is behavior that is perverted, and thus indicates that genre of sin which
deviates from God’s righteous design.
On the Day of Atonement In the Old
Testament sacrificial system the blood of a sacrificial goat was sprinkled
upon the mercy seat overlying the ark of the covenant in the holy of holies,
symbolically depicting that the sins of the people were atoned for or
covered by the blood of the animal. In Leviticus we read that
"on exactly the tenth day of this seventh month is the day of
atonement; it shall be a holy convocation for you, and you shall humble your
souls and present an offering by fire to the LORD. Neither shall you do any
work on this same day, for it is a day of atonement (kippur), to
make atonement (kaphar) on your behalf
before the LORD your God." (Lev 23:27-28)
Moses
describing the actions of the Jewish High Priest on the annual
Day of Atonement records that "he shall slaughter the goat of the sin offering which is
for the people, and bring its blood inside the veil, and do with its blood
as he did with the blood of the bull, and sprinkle it on the mercy seat and
in front of the mercy seat. And he shall make atonement for the holy
place, because of the impurities of the sons of Israel, and because
of their transgressions, in regard to all their sins; and thus
he shall do for the tent of meeting which abides with them in the midst of
their impurities." (Lev
16:15-16).
In the New Testament parallel passages we read that
Jesus
had to be made like His brethren in all things, so that He might
become a merciful and faithful High Priest in things pertaining to God, to
make propitiation (an appeasing sacrifice which was the Perfect
fulfillment to which all the OT sacrifices had pointed) for the sins of
the people. (see note
Hebrews 2:17)
Paul adds of Christ that
God displayed (Him)
publicly (before the eyes of all) as a propitiation (to render
God propitious to us or disposed to be gracious or merciful; ready to
forgive sins and bestow blessings) in His blood through faith. This was
to demonstrate His righteousness, because in the forbearance of God He
passed over the sins previously committed (see note
Romans 3:25)
John adds that Jesus
Himself is the propitiation (the atoning
sacrifice offered once for all time to God to assuage His wrath and render
Him propitious to sinners) for our sins; and not for ours only, but also
for those of the whole world. (1Jn 2:2)
Jesus,
Messiah the Prince, made His atonement available for the sin of Israel when He died on the
Cross, but the efficacy of His atonement will not actually be
realized by Israel as a nation until the individual Jews in Israel personally appropriate
God's gracious gift by receiving
Jesus as their Messiah, Redeemer and Savior. When will this great event
occur?
Paul writes
All Israel will be saved" when "THE DELIVERER
WILL COME FROM ZION, HE WILL REMOVE UNGODLINESS FROM JACOB" (see note
Romans 11:26)
This event will not transpire until the 490 years that have been decreed
have run their full course. In the intervening period (the so called "church
age") leading up to the termination of the 490 years,
Daniel's Seventieth Week, the so-called "Tribulation", individual Jews
have received and will continue to receive Jesus as their Great High Priest
Who has finished His work of atonement on their behalf. Praise the
Lord. Gentile believers must therefore remember and practice Paul's
affirmation...
For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for
it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, to the Jew
first and also to the Greek. (See note
Romans 1:16)
May God grant
that many Jews read
Daniel 9:24-27, have their eyes enlightened to the truth
that their Messiah has come as the perfect, final sacrificial Lamb and by
grace through faith be saved to the uttermost, to the glory of God and His
marvelous plan of salvation for Jews and Gentiles alike. Amen
(4) to
bring in everlasting righteousness:
(Isaiah
51:6,8; 53:11; 56:1; Je 23:5,6; Ro 3:21,22; 1Co 1:30;
2Co 5:21; Php 3:9; He 9:12, 13, 14; 2Pe 1:1;
Re 14:6)
to bring in everlasting righteousness
(permanent moral and spiritual rectitude in every area and relation) (Amp)
righteousness of ages" (Literal)
In short, this item points to the justice
and peace of the new social order in the Millennium inaugurated by Christ's
return.
To bring in (0935)
means literally "to cause to come" and as Barnes notes "refers to some direct
agency by which righteousness would be introduced into the world." There is
a sense in which this was accomplished by Christ in His first coming,
providing the righteous ground by which God would justify (declare
righteous) a believing sinner. The complete fulfillment in regard to Israel
however awaits the return of
the Righteous One, Who
will
crush and put an end to all these kingdoms (including the final
unrighteous Gentile
world power headed by the Antichrist), but it (Messiah's righteous kingdom) will itself endure forever. (everlasting) (Da
2:44)
Then the sovereignty, the dominion, and the greatness of all the
kingdoms under the whole heaven will be given to the people of the saints of
the Highest One; His kingdom will be an everlasting kingdom, and all the
dominions will serve and obey Him. (Da 7:27)
God promises that
days are coming...when I will fulfill the
good word which I have spoken concerning the house of Israel and the house
of Judah (some of that "good word" is promised here in Daniel 9). In
those days and at that time (at the end of the 490 years) I will
cause (emphasizing that God is sovereign and in total control of
history) a righteous Branch of David (Messiah the Prince)
to spring forth; and He shall execute justice and righteousness on
the earth. In those days (during the 1000 years that follow the termination of the 490 years) Judah
shall be saved, and Jerusalem (referring to "your people and your
holy city") shall dwell in safety; and this is the name by which she
(referring to Jerusalem who will take on the same righteous character as the
Messiah Who dwells within her) shall be called: the LORD is our
righteousness.’ (Jer 33:14, 15, 16).
Everlasting (05769)
(olam) means forever, eternity, i.e., pertaining to an
unlimited duration of time, usually with a focus on the future.
Righteousness
(06664)
(tsedeq) is a root which basically connotes conformity to an
ethical or moral standard. The idea is of doing what is required according
to a standard.
Tsedeq - 112v in the OT - Lev.
19:15, 36; Deut. 1:16; 16:18, 20; 25:15; 33:19; Job 6:29; 8:3, 6; 29:14;
31:6; 35:2; 36:3; Ps. 4:1, 5; 7:8, 17; 9:4, 8; 15:2; 17:1, 15; 18:20, 24;
23:3; 35:24, 27f; 37:6; 40:9; 45:4, 7; 48:10; 50:6; 51:19; 52:3; 58:1; 65:5;
72:2; 85:10f, 13; 89:14; 94:15; 96:13; 97:2, 6; 98:9; 118:19; 119:7, 62, 75,
106, 121, 123, 138, 142, 144, 160, 164, 172; 132:9; Prov. 1:3; 2:9; 8:8,
15f; 12:17; 16:13; 25:5; 31:9; Eccl. 3:16; 5:8; 7:15; Isa. 1:21, 26; 11:4f;
16:5; 26:9f; 32:1; 41:2, 10; 42:6, 21; 45:8, 13, 19; 51:1, 5, 7; 58:2, 8;
59:4; 61:3; 62:1f; 64:5; Jer. 11:20; 22:13; 23:6; 31:23; 33:16; 50:7; Ezek.
3:20; 45:10; Dan. 9:24; Hos. 2:19; 10:12; Zeph. 2:3
Messianic passages in the OT envision
righteousness as being applied to the earth at the time of the Second coming
of Messiah (Millennium).
Jeremiah for example writes
Behold, the days are coming," declares
the LORD, "When I shall raise up for David a righteous Branch; And He
will reign as king and act wisely And do justice and righteousness in
the land. In His days Judah will be saved, And Israel will dwell securely;
And this is His name by which He will be called, 'The LORD our
righteousness.' (Jer 23:5-6)
Comment: Compare other passages
which picture the righteous character of the Messianic kingdom -- Je 33:15,
16, 17, 18.
At Messiah's return the "elect" in Israel will believe
in the Messiah and will receive
His righteousness by faith and will be enabled to
live in a right relationship with God and to live according to His will.
Messiah's return will usher in the promised and long awaited Messianic Kingdom
(Millennial Kingdom) which will be characterized by righteousness. Isaiah
describing Messiah's reign declared that
with righteousness He
will judge the poor, and decide with fairness for the afflicted of the
earth; and He will strike the earth with the rod of His mouth, and with the
breath of His lips He will slay the wicked. Also righteousness will
be the belt about His loins, and faithfulness the belt about His waist."
(Isa 11:4, 5)
Peter writes that
according to His promise (one of those promises
being found here in
Daniel 9:24) we are looking for new
heavens and a new earth, in which righteousness dwells." (2Pe
2:13-note)
Comment: This will be an everlasting righteousness for it will continue
through the 1000 year reign of Messiah on earth and into eternity in the New
Heaven and New Earth.
(5) to
seal up vision and prophecy:
(Mt 11:13; Lk 24:25, 26, 27,44,45; Jn 19:28, 29, 30) (Acts 3:22)
to put a seal on a prophet’s vision
(GWT),
to make the vision and prophecy come true (International
Children's Bible),
so that the vision and the prophecy will come true
(TEV),
vision and prophecy may be fulfilled (Darby),
to put a
seal on a prophet's vision (GWT),
to confirm the prophetic vision
(NLT),
confirm what the prophet saw, (Message).
Seal up (02856)
(chatham) means to set a seal on, to seal up. It indicates the
act of affixing an impression to serve as a seal on something, then sealing
it up as well. It can mean to stop, hinder, i.e., stop an event as a
figurative extension of sealing up a document.
Chatham - 24v
in the OT - Lev. 15:3; Deut. 32:34; 1 Ki. 21:8; Neh. 9:38; 10:1; Est. 3:12;
8:8, 10; Job 9:7; 14:17; 24:16; 33:16; 37:7; Cant. 4:12; Isa. 8:16; 29:11;
Jer. 32:10f, 14, 44; Ezek. 28:12; Dan. 9:24; 12:4, 9
Some have interpreted
the phrase (seal up) to suggest that prophecy is to be sealed up and
be kept silent
through the 490 year period (Keil), but even common sense does not support
this interpretation. On the other hand, the legitimate interpretation of this phrase
varies somewhat among conservative scholars, in part because there are 2
Hebrew verbs depending on the manuscript one favors. The NASB and KJV
translate the manuscript with the Hebrew verb (chatham) for seal
up, and can mean to authenticate a document (as when one
finishes a letter and stamps it with a personal seal) or to seal it up and make it securely
enclosed under the seal. This action therefore seems to have a two fold
purpose of authenticating (the prophecy will be shown to be true and will be
completely fulfilled) and of bringing prophecy to a close for when the
prophecy is fulfilled and Messiah has returned after the 490 years, there
will no no longer be needed for vision and prophecy.
Vision
(02377)
(chazown/chazon) means revelation or a communication to others. It
refers to a communication from God to be communicated to others (e.g.,
1Sa 3:1; 1Ch 17:15; 2Ch 32:32; Ps 89:20; Pr 29:18; Is 1:1; 29:7; Je 14:14;
23:16; La 2:9; Ezek 7:13, 26; 12:22, 23, 24, 27; 13:16; Da 1:17)
Chazown/chazon
- 34v in OT - 1Sa 3:1; 1Chr 17:15; 2Chr. 32:32; Ps. 89:19; Pr 29:18; Isa
1:1; 29:7; Je 14:14; 23:16; Lam 2:9; Ezek 7:13, 26; 12:22, 23, 24, 27;
13:16; Da 1:17; 8:1f, 13, 15, 17, 26; 9:21, 24; 10:14; 11:14; Hos. 12:10;
Obad. 1:1; Mic 3:6; Nah 1:1; Hab 2:2, 3
Vine writes
that...
Chazon almost always signifies a means of
divine revelation. First, it refers to the means itself, to a prophetic
“vision” by which divine messages are communicated (Ezek 12:22). Second,
this word represents the message received by prophetic “vision”: “Where
there is no vision, the people perish: but he that keepeth the law,
happy is he” (Pr29:18). Finally, chazon can represent the entirety of a
prophetic or prophet’s message as it is written down: “The vision of
Isaiah the son of Amoz …” (Is 1:1). Thus the word inseparably related to the
content of a divine communication focuses on the means by which that message
is received: “And the word of the Lord was precious in those days; there was
no open vision” (1Sa 3:1— the first occurrence of the word). In Is
29:7 this word signifies a non-prophetic dream.
(Vine,
W E: Vine's Complete Expository Dictionary of Old and New Testament Words.
1996. Nelson)
Prophecy
(05030)
(nabiy) is the word for one who speaks or proclaims the message of a
deity (1Sa 3:20, 1Ki 18:20, La 2:14).
Walvoord writes
that ...
The fifth aspect of the program, "to seal
up the vision and prophecy," is probably best understood to mean the
termination of unusual direct revelation by means of vision and oral
prophecy. The expression to seal up indicates that no more is to be added
and that what has been predicted will receive divine confirmation and
recognition in the form of actual fulfillment. Once a letter is sealed, its
contents are irreversible (cf. Da 6:8). (Ibid)
Charles Feinberg adds that the idea is
to giving the seal of confirmation to Daniel and his vision by fulfilling
his predictions. In Isaiah 8:16, this phrase meant that the prophecy was
complete, and the command was given to bind it up, to roll it up like a
scroll and seal it. Again, in Daniel 8:26 the thought was to seal up the
prophecy and make a permanent record of it, so that when it is fulfilled the
event can be compared to the prophecy to show how completely the one
corresponds to the other.
John Whitcomb explains that
in the post-apostolic phrase of church history, we have no further need of
such ministries, possessing as we do the completed revelation of God in Holy
Scripture. (However) during the first half of the
Seventieth Week
of Daniel
two witnesses will prophesy...but all such prophetic ministries will end
forever at our Lord's return to the earth. (Daniel, Everyman's Bible
Commentary)
(6) to
anoint the most holy
place:
(Psalms 2:6; 45:7; Isaiah 61:1; Luke 4:18-21; John 1:41; 3:34; Hebrews
1:8,9; 9:11) (Mark 1:24; Luke 1:35; Acts 3:14; Hebrews 7:26; Revelation 3:7)
Anoint (04886)
(mashach which is related to Mashiach the word which is
transliterated into English as Messiah, "the anointed One") conveys the basic meaning of to smear something on. The OT
uses of anointing included the setting apart for office or function and thus
to consecrate.
Mashach - 66v in OT - Ge 31:13; Ex
28:41; 29:2, 7, 36; 30:26, 30; 40:9, 10, 11, 13, 15; Lv 2:4; 6:20; 7:12, 36;
8:10, 11, 12; 16:32; Nu 3:3; 6:15; 7:1, 10, 84, 88; 35:25; Jdg 9:8, 15; 1Sa
9:16; 10:1; 15:1, 17; 16:3, 12f; 2Sa 2:4, 7; 3:39; 5:3, 17; 12:7; 19:10;
1Ki. 1:34, 39, 45; 5:1; 19:15, 16; 2 Ki. 9:3, 6, 12; 11:12; 23:30; 1Chr
11:3; 14:8; 29:22; 2Chr 22:7; 23:11; Ps. 45:7; 89:20; Is 21:5; 61:1; Je
22:14; Da 9:24; Amos 6:6 and is rendered in NAS as anoint(21), anointed(42),
anointing(1), oil(1), painting(1), spread(4).
Most holy (06944)
(qodes or qodesh) is a noun which identifies that which has
been consecrated and set aside to be used only for sacred purposes. That
which was qodesh was not to be put to common use lest it become
profaned and rendered "not holy". Qodesh is used some 468 times in 382
verses in the KJV and is translated as -- holy 262, sanctuary 68, (holy,
hallowed,...) things 52, most 44, holiness 30, dedicated 5, hallowed 3,
consecrated 1. Notice that 68 times qodesh refers to the Holy Sanctuary.
The word place is in italics in
the NAS, indicating (in NAS, KJV, NKJV but not in the ESV) that it has been added by the translators.
In other words the original Hebrew literally reads anoint the holy of holies
with no word for "place".
The added word place assumes this to be a
reference to a place rather than to a person (such as "holy one"). The
Septuagint (LXX = Greek translation of the Hebrew)
supports the interpretation as referring to a
place,
translating the Hebrew with the Greek phrase holy of holies,
which is interpreted most naturally as a reference to the inner sanctuary of
the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem. Elsewhere in the
OT, this phrase most holy
is used (37 of 39 occurrences) as a description of a place or an object
and not a person, which is further support that the text is referring to
anointing of the holy place in the Temple and not to the Holy One, Who, the
Messiah.
At the end of the 490 years, the
holy of holies in the Temple on Temple Mount in Jerusalem will be
anointed once again for God’s service. The prophet Ezekiel records
that the Temple will be
rebuilt and this will occur during the time immediately following the Second
Coming of Christ, commonly referred to as the
Millennial (1000 year),
when Messiah will reign for 1000 years on earth (Ezek
40-48). This 1000 year period is based primarily on the repeated
phrase 1000 years (6 times) in Revelation 20. Many who refuse to interpret
the Scriptures literally (where that interpretation is quite reasonable),
take the 1000 years as symbolic, an interpretation generally referred to as
amillennial. It is interesting that many of those who hold this position,
also hold the position that God is finished with Israel and that the
promises made to Israel in the OT have been "defaulted" to the Church. They
base this specious interpretation on a misinterpretation of Galatians 6:16
(see discussion of the phrase
Israel of God).
Those who assume this non-literal interpretation, not surprisingly have
considerable difficulty interpreting the book of the Revelation, which if
taken literally, chronicles the final dealing of God with His chosen people
Israel. It is little wonder (and very sad) that there are such a plethora of
confusing interpretations on the great book of the Revelation.
Ezekiel records that (after the 490 years are completed)
the
glory of the God of Israel (Shekinah Glory -
see study on
The Glory of the LORD)
) was coming from the way of the east (which retraces the departure
of the glory of the LORD as recorded by Ezekiel - Ezek 9:3, 10:4, 18, 19,
11:23, this last location being the Mount of Olives, directly east of
the Eastern Gate and the Holy of holies on Temple Mount). And
His voice was like the sound of many waters (cp John's description of the
glorified Jesus in Re 1:15-note); and the earth shone with His
glory (cp Hab 2:14). And it was like the appearance of the vision which I saw, like the
vision which I saw when He came to destroy the city. And the visions were
like the vision which I saw by the river Chebar; and I fell on my face. And
the glory of the Lord came into the house (the Holy Temple) by the way of the gate facing
toward the east (if you visit Jerusalem today, the Eastern Gate is bricked
shut, but one day in the future it will be opened again to welcome the
return of the Messiah to His holy place!). And the Spirit lifted me up and brought me into the inner
court; and behold, the glory of the Lord filled the house (the
Millennial Temple). Then I heard one speaking to me from the house, while a
man was standing beside me. And He (Messiah is speaking) said to me, "Son of
man, this is the place of My throne and the place of the soles of My feet,
where I will dwell among the sons of Israel forever.... (Ezek 43:2, 3, 4, 5,
6, 7)
Pfeiffer notes that
Most commentators, even many
Amillennialists (those who do note accept a literal 1000 year reign of
Messiah on earth) (e.g., Keil and Leupold) (see related topic:
Millennium),
to whom this passage is somewhat of an embarrassment, feel that this refers
to a renewed Temple, anointed like the Tabernacle of old....
(Pfeiffer,
C F: Wycliffe Bible Commentary. 1981. Moody
or
Logos)
Not everyone agrees that holy place
precludes the idea of holy person, Mills for example writing
that...
The superlative construction translated
‘the most holy’ is literally ‘holy of holy,’ and while it is frequently
interpreted as meaning the holy place (in the temple), this is not
necessarily correct. The noun’s basic idea is to express the nuance of
soundness, wholeness; the Old Testament uses it of God, of places, of
things, of times and of persons, and it is particularly used of the altar.
However, as the preceding parts of God’s program refer to the eternal state,
it seems unlikely that this clause returns to the mundane and temporal; I am
thus persuaded that this clause refers to the Most Holy person, the Lamb of
God (Revelation 5) Who will be anointed God’s eternal prince, the King of
Kings and Lord of Lords (Rev 19:16), for in the eternal state there will be
no temple and thus no altar (Rev 21:22). (Mills, M. Daniel: A Study Guide to
the Book of Daniel. Dallas: 3E Ministries)
Richison sums up this introductory
verse writing that...
God will accomplish these six things in
anticipation of the Millennial kingdom. These things summarize God’s program
to be true to His unconditional covenants such as the Abrahamic Covenant
(see
Abrahamic versus Mosaic),
the Davidic Covenant and the New Covenant (see
New Covenant in the Old Testament
or
Why the New is Better
or
Covenant: Abrahamic vs Old vs New).
God already fulfilled some of these purposes. God will complete His program
for these six purposes when the 490 years run their course. This program
involves: 1) delivering Jews from the Babylonian captivity, 2) delivering
them from sin at the Messiah’s advent, and 3) complete deliverance from
oppression at the Second Coming of Christ.
><>><>><>
In
the seventeenth century a very learned Jew published a book in which he set
forth the claims of Jesus Christ to be the Jewish Messiah. In the preface to
the book he told how he himself had been converted by listening to a debate
between a knowledgeable Jew and a Christian convert from Judaism over the
meaning of Daniel 9:24-27. The moderator of the debate was a learned rabbi,
and as the Christian pressed the claims of this passage home it became so
clear that the passage was pointing to Jesus Christ that the rabbi closed
the debate with these words
Let us shut up our
books, for if
we go on examining the prophecy we shall all become Christians. (Amen and
Amen!)
><>><>><>
The seventy weeks prophecy of Daniel
9:24-27 was originally regarded by the rabbis as one of the most important
predictive texts in the Bible. This significance was testified to by the
first-century Jewish historian Flavius Josephus
He [Daniel] not
only
predicted the future, like the other prophets, but specified when the events
would happen (Antiquities x. 268). (Click
and scroll down
for Randall Price's history of
rabbinic interpretation of
Daniel's Seventieth Week)
><>><>><>
Leopold Cohn
(pictured below -
click additional notes on his life) was
born into an Orthodox Jewish community in Berezna, a small town in eastern
Hungary in 1862. At age 18 he graduated with high marks from the Talmudic
academy and became a rabbi. One of his rituals was to daily repeat the 12th
article of the Jewish creed:
I believe with a perfect faith in the
coming of the Messiah, and though he tarry, yet will I wait daily for his
coming.
Cohn however wondered
why Messiah tarried, but was unsettled by the "answers" he able to find.
While reading the Talmud (collected writings of rabbis
commenting
on the Torah or Old Testament), he discovered that other rabbis had also
wrestled with this question. But as he continued to study he discovered that
the Messiah should have come long ago. This prompted him to study the Hebrew
prophets for himself, and as he studied Daniel’s prophecy of the "70
weeks" in Daniel 9:24-27, it became clear that Daniel had
predicted the coming of Messiah some 400-500 years after the prophecy was
given. But that was 2500 years ago and the rabbis said that Messiah had not
yet come. How could he resolve this contradiction? An older rabbi who served
as Cohn's mentor advised him to drop the subject altogether or he might lose
his rabbinical career because such questions were not to be asked. The rabbi
further explained that he could not discuss the matter without losing his
own job. He even advised Cohn to go to America where, he said, people knew
more about the Messiah. Later, Leopold Cohn recalled this incident and felt
that the rabbi knew something about the Messiah, Jesus. And so in 1892 Cohn
left Hungary for New York City in search of the truth about the Messiah
prompted by his study of Daniel's "Seventy weeks". On one providential day,
Cohn happened to pass by a church in the Jewish section of the city and
noticed a small sign advertising "Meetings for Jews." It was at that meeting
that Cohn met another Jewish an also trained in the Talmud. It was there
that Leopold Cohn was given a copy of the New Testament which he read
straight though beginning at 11:00 one morning and finishing at 1:00 AM the
next day, upon which he concluded that Yeshua (Jesus) was indeed the
promised Messiah prophesied by Daniel to come and be cut off. Soon
thereafter he received Yeshua, Jesus, as his Messiah, Savior and Lord. With
his new found faith, he begin to go to his people, the Jews, and in Cohn's
words
I showed them from the Scriptures that to
believe in Yeshua was Jewish faith, real Jewish faith.
What followed was
sorrow, travail and persecution from other Jews because of his presumed
"betrayal" of their orthodox faith. In 1894 Cohn set up a storefront mission
in a renovated horse stable in the Brownsville section of Brooklyn, New York
for the sole purpose of telling others that the Messiah had come and that
his name was Yeshua, Jesus. The first Bible meeting was attended by eight
Jewish people. The Lord continued to bless this work, and in the course of
his lifetime, Leopold Cohn led over 1,000 people to the Lord. His local
mission eventually became the American Board of Missions to the Jews, which
was later re-named
Chosen People Ministries.
Over 50 years later a man named Moishe Rosen left that ministry to form what
eventually became
Jews for Jesus. This one passage,
Daniel 9:24-27, radically changed an Orthodox Jewish rabbi and led to the
birthing of ministries that have touched literally thousands of Jewish and
Gentile lives around the world.
><> ><> ><>
Donald Campbell former president of Dallas Theological Seminary has an
interesting anecdotal story
Two Christians,
observing the model of first-century Jerusalem at the Holy Land Hotel in
that city, were discussing in particular the future rebuilding of the
temple. A stranger stood nearby listening to their conversation and then
introduced himself as a New York rabbi. He asked in amazement,
"Do Christians really believe in the
rebuilding of a temple in Jerusalem?"
"Haven't you read your prophets, Ezekiel and Daniel? one of
the Christians replied.
"No," the rabbi admitted, "because when I was studying to be a rabbi I was
told not to read Daniel and was particularly forbidden to compute the
prophecy of the seventy weeks in Daniel, chapter 9!"
The reason for such a prohibition? Because the prophetic books, especially
Daniel 9, show that Messiah has already come.
An ancient rabbi said,
"Let the bones of those who reckon the
times tremble."
(To which Campbell responds)
Rather may it be said, "let the hearts of
those who reckon the times rejoice! For Messiah has come and provided
salvation for all who believe. (Daniel: God's Man in a Secular Society:
Discovery House Publishing, 198) |