TO THE PURE
ALL THINGS ARE PURE: panta men kathara tois katharois: (Lu 11:39-41;
Acts 10:15;
Ro 14:14;
14:20
1Cor 6:12;
6:13
10:23;
10:25
10:31
1Ti 4:3
4:4)
Everything is clean to those who are clean (GWT)
Everything is pure to those whose hearts are pure (NLT)
Everything is wholesome to those who are themselves wholesome (Phillips)
A person who is pure of heart sees goodness and purity in everything
(TLB)
To the pure [in heart and conscience] all things are pure (Amp)
MacArthur sums up this passage noting
that
Paul gives two divinely inspired evaluations of false teachers in the
Cretan churches, evaluations that apply to false teachers in any age.
First he assesses their inner lives and finds them to be corrupt. He
then assesses their outer lives and finds them to be hypocritical and
debauched. (MacArthur.
Titus: Moody Press)
MacDonald sounds a note of caution in
the interpretation of this verse and gives a well reasoned exposition,
declaring that
If we take the words
to the pure all things are pure
out of context as a statement of absolute truth in all areas of life, we
are in trouble! All things are not pure, even to those whose minds are
pure. Yet people have actually used this verse to justify vile
magazines, suggestive movies, and even immorality itself.
Let it be clearly understood that this verse has absolutely nothing to
do with things that are sinful in themselves and condemned in the
Bible...This proverbial saying must be understood in the light of the
context. Paul has not been speaking about matters of clear-cut morality,
of things that are inherently right or wrong. Rather, he has been
discussing matters of moral indifference, things that were ceremonially
defiling for a Jew living under the law but that are perfectly
legitimate for a Christian living under grace. The obvious example is
the eating of pork. It was forbidden to God’s people in the OT, but the
Lord Jesus changed all that when He said that nothing entering into a
man can defile him (Mk 7:15).
In saying this He pronounced all foods clean (Mk 7:19).
Paul echoed this truth when he said: “But food does not commend us to
God; for neither if we eat are we the better, nor if we do not eat are
we the worse” (1Cor 8:8).
When he says: “To
the pure all things are
pure,”
he means that to the born again believer all foods are clean, but to
those who are defiled and unbelieving nothing is pure . It is not what a
person eats that defiles him but what comes out of his heart (Mk 7:20
21
22
23).
If a man’s inner life is impure, if he does not have faith in the Lord
Jesus, then nothing is pure to him. The observance of dietary rules
won’t do a thing for him. More than anything else he needs to be
converted, to receive salvation as a free gift rather than trying to
earn it through rituals and legalism. The very minds and consciences of
defiled people are corrupted. Their mental processes and their moral
powers are defiled. It is not a question of external ceremonial
defilement, but of inward corruption and depravity. (MacDonald,
W., & Farstad, A. Believer's Bible Commentary: Old and New Testaments.
Nashville: Thomas Nelson)
Pure
(2513)
(katharos; English = catharsis = purifying,
cleansing, a term used in psychology and counseling for a cleansing of
the mind or emotions - a "soul cleansing" if you will; cathartic
= any substance used to induce purging or to cleanse a wound or infected
are in order to make it pure; Cathar = member of a medieval sect
which sought the purging of all evil from its members) literally
describes that which is free of dirt and thus clean. It describes
that which is free from admixture or adulteration and thus is pure.
From a biblical standpoint the concept of cleansing is deeply rooted in
both the Old and the New Testaments. As discussed more below under the
Levitical laws heavy emphasis was placed on ceremonial cleansing and
thus contact with any unclean animal, substance, person, or place was
strictly forbidden. By the time Christ came this preoccupation with
ceremonial cleanness had unfortunately displaced true worship with many
of the Jews, most notably the Pharisees. It is not surprising then that
the New Testament focuses mainly on an inward cleanness (heart,
conscience), rather than on an external or ceremonial cleanness.
It is also worth
noting that katharos is related to the Latin castus, from which
we get chaste. The related word chasten refers to discipline given in
order to cleanse from wrong behavior.
Katharos is
blameless, innocent, unstained with the guilt and is used to describe
that which is ceremonially or ritually pure or clean (in a "Levitical
sense"). For example Moses records...
Leviticus 6:11 'Then he shall
take off his garments and put on other garments, and carry the ashes
outside the camp to a clean (LXX
= katharos) place.
Exodus 25:11 "And you shall
overlay it (the Ark of the Covenant) with pure (LXX
= katharos) gold, inside and out you shall overlay it, and you shall
make a gold molding around it.
Katharos is
an adjective that figuratively is used in both the OT and the NT to
describe the state of one's heart. When a person is
pure
in heart and mind, his or her perspective on all things is pure, and
that inner purity produces outer purity. As discussed above, true purity
lies not in adherence to external commandments of men but in the inner
purity of the redeemed, regenerated heart.
Katharos is
used to modify conscience (clean, clear) and religion
(pure).
Wuest
writes that katharos means...
clean, pure, free from the adhesion
of anything that soils, adulterates, corrupts, and in an ethical sense,
“free from corrupt desire, sin, and guilt.
(Wuest,
K. S. Wuest's Word Studies from the Greek New Testament: Eerdmans
or
Logos)
MacArthur
writes that...
katharos has two shades of
meaning. Some suggest that it also means unmixed or unalloyed or
unadulterated or sifted or cleansed of chaff. In other words, to be pure
means you have no added mixture of any foreign element. Thus, what our
Lord was really saying here is, “I desire a heart that is unmixed in
its devotion and motivation. Pure motives from a pure heart.”Either
way, it has to do with attitudes, integrity, and singleness of heart as
opposed to duplicity and double mindedness (MacArthur, J. The Only Way
to Happiness: The Beatitudes. Chicago: Moody Press)
NIDNTT
writes that in classical Greek...
The adjective katharos (derivation
obscure, probably nothing to do with Latin castus) is common from Homer
onwards, and means: (a) originally, clean, in a physical sense as
opposed to rhuparos = dirty (e.g. pure, clean water, Eur. Hippolytus
209); (b) clean, in the sense of free, without things which come
between, as opposed to pleres or mestos, full (e.g. en katharo, Homer
Il. 23, 61); (c) ritually clean, as opposed to akathartos, unclean; (d)
in a religious sense, morally pure (e.g. katharos adikias, Plato,
Republic 6, 496d; katharos cheiras, Hdt., 1, 35)...
In the LXX katharos renders 18
different Heb. equivalents, but by far the most frequent is tahôr, in
the sense of ritual purity. Occasionally the LXX also translates the
Heb. naqî, pure, innocent (Job 4:7), and zakak, to be bright, pure,
innocent (Job 15:15) by katharos. (Brown,
Colin, Editor. New International Dictionary of NT Theology. 1986.
Zondervan)
Richards
gives a good background summary of the general terms clean and unclean
noting that...
The concept of cleanness and
uncleanness has roots in the ritual worship of Israel. God chose
to identify some things and actions as "unclean." Individuals in an
unclean condition were not permitted to participate in Israel's worship.
But such individuals could be cleansed and again take part in worship.
The ceremonial concepts of cleanness and uncleanness were also used to
clarify the concepts of sin and atonement. It is this moral aspect of
the terms that the prophets emphasized. Israel was spiritually and
morally unclean and had to look to the future, hoping for God to act and
bring supernatural inner cleansing.
The religious leaders of Jesus' day were blind to the emphasis of the
prophets. They focused on the ritual minutia. Jesus announced that
cleanness and uncleanness are matters of the heart. He did away with the
old classification of clean and unclean foods. This lesson was
reiterated to the young Hebrew-Christian church through Peter's vision.
God now deals with the heart: the OT symbols have been supplanted by the
realities they symbolized but could never accomplish. (Richards,
L O: Expository Dictionary of Bible Words: Regency)
MacArthur
(commenting on Mt 5:8 "pure in heart") explains that in secular Greek
usage katharos...
was often used of metals that had
been refined until all impurities were removed, leaving only the pure
metal. In that sense, purity means unmixed, unalloyed, unadulterated.
Applied to the heart, the idea is that of pure motive-of
single-mindedness, undivided devotion, spiritual integrity, and true
righteousness. (MacArthur,
J: Matthew 1-7 Chicago: Moody Press
or
Logos)
Barclay
writes that...
In its positive form (katharos,
an adjective meaning pure) it is commonly used in housing contracts to
describe a house that is left clean and in good condition. But its most
suggestive use is that katharos is used of that ceremonial
cleanness which entitles a man to approach his gods. Impurity, then, is
that which makes a man unfit to come before God, the soiling of life
with the things which separate us from him.
Katharos "originally simply
meant clean as opposed to soiled or dirty. Later it came to have certain
most suggestive uses. It was used of corn that has been winnowed and
cleansed of all chaff. It was used of an army which had been purified of
all cowardly and undisciplined soldiers until there was nothing left but
first-class fighting men. It was used of something which was without any
debasing admixture. So, then, a pure heart (as in
2 Timothy 2:22 [note])
is a heart whose motives are absolutely pure and absolutely unmixed. In
the heart of the Christian thinker there is no desire to show how clever
he is, no desire to win a purely debating victory, no desire to show up
the ignorance of his opponent. His only desire is to help and to
illumine and to lead nearer to God. The Christian thinker is moved only
by love of truth and love for men. (Barclay,
W: The Daily Study Bible Series. The Westminster Press
or
Logos)
Barclay in
his comments on
Matthew 5:8 (note)
explains...
The Greek word for pure is
katharos, and it has a variety of usages, all of which have
something to add to the meaning of this beatitude for the Christian
life.
(i) Originally it simply meant clean,
and could, for instance, be used of soiled clothes which have been
washed clean.
(ii) It is regularly used for corn
which has been winnowed or sifted and cleansed of all chaff. In the same
way it is used of an army which has been purged of all discontented,
cowardly, unwilling and inefficient soldiers, and which is a force
composed solely of first-class fighting men.
(iii) It very commonly appears in
company with another Greek adjective—akēratos. Akēratos can be used of
milk or wine which is unadulterated with water, or of metal which has in
it no tinge of alloy.
So, then, the basic meaning of
katharos is unmixed, unadulterated, unalloyed. That is why this
beatitude is so demanding a beatitude. It could be translated:
Blessed is the man whose motives are
always entirely unmixed, for that man shall see God.
It is very seldom indeed that we do
even our finest actions from absolutely unmixed motives. If we give
generously and liberally to some good cause, it may be that there
lingers in the depths of our hearts some contentment in basking in the
sunshine of our own self-approval, some pleasure in the praise and
thanks and credit which we will receive. If we do some fine thing, which
demands some sacrifice from us, it may well be that we are not
altogether free from the feeling that men will see something heroic in
us and that we may regard ourselves as martyrs. Even a preacher at his
most sincere is not altogether free from the danger of self-satisfaction
in having preached a good sermon. Was it not John Bunyan who was once
told by someone that he had preached well that day, and who answered
sadly, “The devil already told me that as I was coming down the pulpit
steps” (Barclay,
W: The Daily Study Bible Series. The Westminster Press
or
Logos)
Here are the 27
uses of katharos in the NT translated clean(12), clear(3),
innocent (1), pure(10 + 1x in KJV only)...
Matthew 5:8 (note)
"Blessed are the pure in heart (see representative uses in the
Septuagint below), for they shall see God. (Comment: Jesus is
speaking not just of pure motives, but also of pure or holy deeds. As
Puritan Thomas Watson once said "Morality can drown a man as fast as
vice." and "A vessel may sink with gold or with dung". You can say,
“I’m a very religious person and want to please God,” but if your
deeds are not according to His Word and they do not reveal a real
purity, it does not matter.)
Matthew 23:26 "You blind
Pharisee, first clean the inside of the cup and of the dish, so that the
outside of it may become clean also.
Matthew 27:59 And Joseph took
the body and wrapped it in a clean linen cloth,
Luke 11:41 "But give that
which is within as charity, and then all things are clean for
you.
John 13:10 Jesus said to him,
"He who has bathed needs only to wash his feet, but is completely
clean; and you are clean, but not all of you."
John 13:11 For He knew the one who was betraying Him; for this
reason He said, "Not all of you are clean." (Comment:
Katharos is used figuratively in a moral or spiritual sense to
describe that which is free of wrongdoing and is thus "pure", "clean" or
"good" in God's sight.)
John 15:3 "You are already
clean because of the word which I have spoken to you. (Comment:
Thayer explains that here "the idea which Christ expresses figuratively
is as follows: `he whose inmost nature has been renovated does not need
radical renewal, but only to be cleansed from every several fault into
which he may fall through contact with the unrenewed world")
Acts 18:6 And when they
resisted and blasphemed, he shook out his garments and said to them,
"Your blood be upon your own heads! I am clean. From now on I
shall go to the Gentiles."
Acts 20:26 "Therefore I
testify to you this day, that I am innocent of the blood of all
men.
Romans 14:20 (note)
Do not tear down the
work of God for the sake of food. All things indeed are clean,
but they are evil for the man who eats and gives offense. (Comment:
In a Levitical sense katharos here speaks of a use of which is not
forbidden or which imparts no uncleanness.)
1 Timothy 1:5 But the goal of
our instruction is love from a pure heart and a good conscience
and a sincere faith.
1 Timothy 3:9 but holding to
the mystery of the faith with a clear conscience.
2 Timothy 1:3 (note)
I thank God, whom
I serve with a clear conscience the way my forefathers did, as I
constantly remember you in my prayers night and day,
2 Timothy 2:22 (note)
Now flee from youthful lusts, and pursue righteousness, faith, love and
peace, with those who call on the Lord from a pure heart.
Titus 1:15
To the pure, all things are pure; but to those who are
defiled and unbelieving, nothing is pure, but both their mind and
their conscience are defiled.
Hebrews 10:22 (note)
let us draw near with a sincere heart in full assurance of faith, having
our hearts sprinkled clean from an evil conscience and our bodies washed
with pure water.
James 1:27 This is pure
and undefiled religion in the sight of our God and Father, to visit
orphans and widows in their distress, and to keep oneself unstained by
the world.
1 Peter 1:22 (note)
Since you have in obedience to the truth purified your souls for a
sincere love of the brethren, fervently love one another from the heart,
(KJV - "see that ye love one another with a pure heart fervently"
- NAS does not translate katharos).
Observe how
katharos characterizes the Bride of Christ and the things of heaven.
What a glorious future we have to look forward too, beloved!
Revelation 15:6 (note)
and the seven angels who had the seven plagues came out of the temple,
clothed in linen, clean and bright, and girded around their
breasts with golden girdles.
Revelation 19:8 (note)
And it was given to her to clothe herself in fine linen, bright and
clean; for the fine linen is the righteous acts of the saints.
Revelation 19:14 (note)
And the armies which are in heaven, clothed in fine linen,
white and clean, were following Him on white horses.
Revelation